Thanks for visiting - Crew Skills has retired! If you'd like to catch up with what I'm playing and writing lately, check out Siha Games!, my general MMO and gaming blog.

28 September 2011 7 Comments

Why I Enjoy Crafting

Before I get started on dishing up actual crafting info, I wanted to take a moment to talk about why I care about crafting systems; why it’s a part of the game that I think is important enough to blog about.

I’ve rambled about this at friends quite a lot over the years, in one way or another, and most recently I had to get my thoughts in order to explain to Dee at exactly why I liked crafting.

SWG's crafting interface My enthusiasm for this aspect of game systems has often baffled friends whose experience with MMOs has been limited to games like WoW and RIFT with their extremely linear, uncompelling tradeskills systems. My first MMO was Star Wars Galaxies; SWG alumni can be found all over the MMO-gaming landscape mourning the loss of its brilliant crafting system.

(Okay, my first MMO was technically Ultima Online; however, that was many years before SWG, and I barely remember anything about it. Lord knows how I managed to miss the EQ bandwagon when my UO guild migrated there.)

I won’t fill this post with hundreds of words about what made SWG’s crafting system so unique (as I already did to poor Dee’s comments); instead I’ll summarise:

SWG’s system:

  • produced crafted items of better quality when the raw materials were of higher quality;
  • produced items of better quality when the crafter had put more effort into maximising their character’s crafting skills;
  • allowed the crafter to vary the item’s stats or other attributes (like colour and name), creating customised products;
  • required the crafter to sacrifice other parts of gameplay to be a crafter (ie. spending skill points on crafting meant you couldn’t spend them on combat skills), so the market was never glutted;
  • allowed the grindy part of producing items in bulk to be automated in ‘factory’ facilities while the player went off to do something fun;
  • was complex enough that player skill played a significant part in the outcome of the process (eg in selecting the best raw materials or making intelligent customisation choices); and
  • had a meaningful chance of failure (raw materials used, end product failed or useless)

SWG's crafting interface - the Experimentation window The important part is not SWG’s specific game mechanics or how they implemented these principles; it’s the principles themselves. In a well-designed crafting system, a dedicated crafter can set themselves apart with a higher-quality or rarer finished product because they know the system better and have dedicated the time to master it, in the same way that an expert raider or PvPer can distinguish themselves by their skill.

And that’s what I like about crafting – or, more accurately, about good crafting systems. Implemented properly, they’re not just a grindy break from killing people or monsters, they’re an interesting part of gameplay in their own right.

How will dedicated crafters find SW:TOR? Well… we don’t know yet. Most information is still locked up tight under NDA; we know what the crafting skills are (and I’ll be presenting a guide about that soon), but we don’t know much yet about how they’ll be pursued. However, Game Director James Ohlen went on the record at Pax Prime as saying that if you want to be a level 1 crafter, you can. This does suggest that the devs are aware that some people play to craft and enjoy a meaningful crafting-centric game style, so we can only hope that this translates into an enjoyable, complex, satisfying tradeskills system in-game.

Image credit: The image of SWG’s crafting interface was taken from a post on the Sony SWG forums which may disappear when the game finally goes dark in mid-December 2011. The image of the experimentation interface was taken from a post on The Chosen Ones’ guild forum.

7 Responses to “Why I Enjoy Crafting”

  1. Dee 28 September 2011 at 18:36 #

    I dunno what your thoughts on NDA breaches are, so I’m not sure how much of the crew skills system in SWtOR you’ve seen, but… it looks kinda interesting. Like, not as “hardcore” as SWG but not as point-and-click as WoW; there seem to actually be choices you can make to assemble gear (some gear?) in different configurations. Gear that’s, like, useful too.

    IDK. You know my thoughts on crafting but it’s almost tempting to take it. Maybe on a bank alt or something (save the missions skills/gathering for my main?).

    If I ever get into a beta weekend (hah!) it’ll definitely be the first thing I look into, I think…

    • Siha 28 September 2011 at 23:07 #

      I was actually avoiding beta info until the NDA was lifted because I’d been planning this blog for a while (although it was still nebulous at this stage) and I didn’t want to have a head full of things I couldn’t blog about. And, too, betas involve a lot of flux and I didn’t want to fixate on ideas that got scrapped or significantly change.

      That said, now that the release date is set, and only three months away, I might start looking for more concrete info.

      • Dee 29 September 2011 at 08:42 #

        Heh. My attitude to NDA breaches tends to be, “So long as I’m not the one breaching contract…” so… yeah, lol. But fair enough.

        (And, yanno. I’m addicted to watching gameplay footage, which is why I haven’t been to bed before midnight for like the last month. Erp. 6^^)

  2. Skarrde 1 October 2011 at 01:35 #

    Looking forward to reading your blog on this. Was a fan of Banana Shoulders, especially your coverage of Wrath, and look forward to the information that you will put forth on this as well.


  1. Why I Enjoy Crafting | Crew Skills [ AZEROTH. ME. ] - September 28, 2011

    […] Why I Enjoy Crafting | Crew Skills. […]

  2. What makes good crafting great? – Siha Games! - June 27, 2012

    […] a while about what makes for an engaging crafting system. I talked about it with Dee over at 6D. I expanded on those ideas at Crew Skills, my SWTOR crafting blog. I’ve debated this with guildies, too, and for many […]

  3. Moving On – CrewSkills – Crew Skills - August 6, 2012

    […] the deep and engrossing crafting system they promised us — at least, not by my standards of why I enjoy tradeskills or what makes a crafting system […]

Leave a Reply